A free-standing last part of an article series on delusional madness. Part 1 here and part 2 here.
I have six children. To five of those I have, I hope, good relations. To one of those I haven't spoken for almost a year. At the age of 15, she left our family due to delusional mental illness. First, she accused her parents of psychological abuse. Then she went on to accuse her foster parents of psychological abuse. In poetically worded letters to every instance of authority, she laments the bad treatment she endures and threatens hunger strikes if her demands of a proper home environment are not being met. As things are, it is unclear whether psychiatry will investigate the cause behind this strange line of behavior.
For a mainstream Western parent, being left by a child this way constitutes an almost unspeakable tragedy. But there is a population category for which it should be much more normal that teenagers leave their families: People from religious subcultures. No religious group has a hundred percent retention rate. Some children simply get lost on the way.
I have only read about such cases from the side of the lost child. Never from the side of the parents. Most probably this topic is slightly taboo in religious communities. Just like it is slightly taboo in mainstream society to talk about parenting failures.
But this taboo only applies to parents. Modern literature and the internet are filled with testimonies from children who are dissatisfied with their parents and have broken off with them. For every such story there must also be a counter-story from the perspective of the parents. But I don’t find those stories, except occasionally, hidden in some obscure Reddit thread, covered in anonymity.
Deeply religious parents who lose a child to the secular world have a straightforward choice to make. They can either stick to their religion and lose their child or they can stick to their child and lose their religion. Most choose their religion, remain in their communities and let their wayward children drift off in solitude. But at least they have a choice.
For us in mainstream culture it is not that simple. We are supposed to always support our children, even (or maybe especially) our socially deviant children. But when my daughter disappeared I acutely felt the choice of the religious. Although I do not have a religious community to stick to, I do have a family. And I sensed that the form of therapy culture that my daughter was signing up to was fundamentally against family. My choice not to pursue her was fundamentally an ideological choice: Against unbridled individualism, in favor of a world-view where right and wrong exists.
A story from the other side
Since my teenage daughter left, I have gotten more acquainted with my ideological opponents. One of the most vocal of those is called Harry Thompson and has written a book called The PDA Paradox. PDA is short for Pathological Demand Avoidance and the book is the story of Harry’s own life, written when he was 23 years old.
Publicly reviewing other people's personalities is not a nice habit. I'm making an exception here, because Harry Thompson's book is an ideological statement centered around his personality type. I can't express an opinion on his advice to families and society as a whole without simultaneously expressing an opinion on his personality.
Harry Thompson has Pathological Demand Avoidance. That means that he finds it very difficult to adapt to the interests of other people, unless he can be convinced that those interests are his interests. In other words, Harry Thompson is a jerk. On page after page, he describes what a jerk he has been throughout his life. He was over-sensitive to sounds and raged if someone else unwittingly displeased his ears, but just had to make the most annoying sounds possible to the maximum number of people. He couldn't accept the idea of being one of the crowd, so he always needed to make a fool of himself, or worse, to stay in the center of people's attention. As a teenager he could throw the worst insults possible on people for no other reason than this compelling preference for everyone's attention.
Harry recognizes that he has behaved inappropriately many times. But at the age of 23, he appears to still hold a world-view where he is the center around which everything else circles. Although he admits that he sometimes did wrong, he still tries very little to see the world from someone else's perspective. For example, Harry explains why he can't hold down a job:
“What I have found is that many people, particularly employers, perceive my behaviour as arrogant when really I’m just refusing to engage in something, or with someone, I don’t chime with. What my employers didn’t realise is that most of my days at work are spent in survival mode, whereby all of my energy is used to protect myself from any oncoming fire and to parry the insane impulses I get.”1
“In the workplace, one is expected to uphold a certain ethic. So here we can immediately see how someone like myself will incur a problem, because if something doesn’t feel right to me then I find it nearly impossible to do it. ‘Can you change the light bulb?’ or ‘Can you be polite to customers?’ could be like someone asking me to murder several family members before taking a bullet myself.”2
“Imagine if, for the rest of your life, you were forced to work as a toilet cleaner but you were only allowed to use your tongue? Well that’s a little how I sometimes feel when I am faced with working the simplest and most mundane of jobs. I am not only pouring my efforts into doing a job properly like everyone else is, but I am simultaneously battling to keep a hold of my sanity.”3
These poetic descriptions of what it is like to hate working could have made some sense, if it in any way benchmarked against the bad feelings the average person gets from having a job. After all, there is a reason why people get paid to work: Many, if not most people, really would rather do something else than working jobs that require no other skill than obedience and conformity. There is a reason why people incur massive student debt: they hope to avoid spending eight hours a day just obeying. And among people in general, feeling bad at work is very common. “Problems at work” are frequently cited as the reason behind mental health issues in the general population. So Harry and carbon copies of him can hardly be the only ones who suffer through their workdays. But Harry writes very little about his supposition about other people's feelings. The “neurotypicals” appear as just a gray mass to shine against, passed into the subordinate clauses.
Against this background, the most absurd thing in Harry's personality is his unshakable sense of justice. He tells about how he ended his job at a restaurant:
“On my last day working at that restaurant, I got a little bit cranky with a customer. She was sitting inside alone at a small table and approached me to ask if she could sit at the big outside table with the wicker chairs. I said no because the tables were reserved, and she was by herself. She asked again in a more exigent tone as if she hadn’t listened to a blind word I said. ‘Look, do you see anyone else whining? You are no more important than anyone else!’ I exclaimed. She was a bit hurt by my snapping at her and told me I was rude. About a half hour later the manager sat me down and asked me why I sometimes had such a searing lip with people. I told her that after living life on the road, I have zero tolerance for injustice, entitlement or first world bulls***, but those who do not exhibit such traits, I will treat with love and respect. I then went and sat down with a few other employees when my shift had finished as I wanted to say goodbye to them. Everyone was having a giggle about my recent altercation.”4
After a life of doing his utmost to get special treatment (and succeeding quite a bit, Harry's parents were rather rich and could afford to send him to expensive special schools), Harry can absolutely not understand why anyone except him would be anything else than perfectly moral. Could he be expected to put up with some of other people's bad sides? No way! It is other people who are supposed to put up with his bad sides, because he is such a brightly shining star. The book ends with a short text by his mother, essentially saying exactly that: That Harry has such a colorful personality.
Down the slippery slope
Harry is a self-described pathologically self-centered person who is proud of himself. He urges other pathologically self-centered people to also be proud of themselves. How can he find pride in this condition? That is not entirely clear to me, but he seems to reason that since being self-centered is his very personality, it must be good, because personalities are holy. Harry doesn't exhibit any sense of need to argue that his personality is useful for others. It is his way of being and that is more than enough, it seems.
How did we end up here? I'm usually no fan of slippery slope argumentation. But here I think we actually have a real-world slippery slope in action: It is the ideology of every person's equal value that has run its course to the degree that obvious social pathologies are being counted as of equal value.
It didn't happen at once. It happened very slowly, step by step, as society moved from a moral where the purpose of the individual was to serve something bigger, to a moral where the purpose of society was to serve the individual.
The first steps seemed like win-wins for the individual and society. Freedom of religion. Freedom of speech. Freedom from oppressive sexuality norms. The idea that the interests of the individual and society sometimes coincide slowly transformed into the idea that the happiness of the individual is the very purpose of society.
It happened gradually over a long time. But I think gender ideology is the most obvious manifestation of this shift in norms. A person going through expensive and hazardous plastic surgery with the purpose of looking like a person of the opposite sex practically can't benefit anyone but the individual involved. For everyone else, there are most of all externalities. Most notably, confusion over privileges our society is giving women, like the right to segregation in vulnerable situations or sports and young people who believe they need to actively choose their gender.
The opponents of gender ideology largely stand defenceless against the underlying individualist ideology. In theory, they could have said that people should not change sex because people are much more useful to other people and society the way they are. But the idea that the individual should be useful to anyone but themselves is not very fashionable at the moment. So the vast anti-trans movement instead focuses on proving that people don't get happier from imitating the opposite sex after all or that people doing so cause unacceptable externalities. All sides of the debate accept the premise that the only purpose of the individual is the happiness of the individual.
What is the logical continuation of that idea? It must be Jerk Pride: Individuals who recognize that they need to be allowed to be jerks in order to be happy and who kindly ask society to adapt and build reserves where jerks can be jerks without causing too much externalities for others. At the very least, natural jerks should be allowed to act their nature as long as they are children, the reasoning goes. Shouldn't society adapt as much as possible to natural born jerks, now that it adapts to everyone else with needs?
Raising kids in a mental hospital
When my teenage daughter chose to leave our family, I finally broke up with that extremely individual-centered ideology. I didn't like it in particular before that either. But I nonetheless followed it to a rather high degree, because I could see no other possible way of handling things.
Although my daughter isn't officially diagnosed with Pathological Demand Avoidance, she quite obviously avoids demands in a pathological way. And I became an expert at handling it. I knew that if I failed to make Alma feel good enough, she would run away, in the worst case forcing us to call the police to locate her (this happened a number of times). She would throw furniture. She would break something that I would have to fix or replace. I became good at avoiding those pitfalls. Rule number one was: Never, ever express any indication of moral disapproval. Not even a slight tone of annoyment. Always be polite and ask nicely. And if I needed to make an outright demand, like please don't break the house, I had to formulate it legalistically and logically and make statements like This is my house so you have no right to break it. That way, I didn't have to ask her to make a concession to me and my interests: I only stated a fact.
That way I could handle much of the most visible damage. I was so good at it that it became my job. Anders never learned those tricks. Instead, he made demands on me: I should tell Alma to do this and that (wash her dishes, eat the food she made two days ago before it got bad… good luck with that!) As time went on, I found the burden more and more heavy to carry alone. In order to make the situation manageable, I tried to convince Anders of the concept This is a mental hospital and in this mental hospital we... That way, I explained that the only way I could keep things reasonably calm, was to treat Alma like a patient. I didn't think that, for example, systematically throwing away food and calling family members demeaning names is right for real. I just needed to cooperate with that kind of behavior to keep things afloat at all.
This cooperation with mental illness was the worst part of living with mental illness. My job dealing with an insane person forced me to behave in ways that I didn't recognize as fully sane myself.
When Alma first moved out, I kept on worrying about her. How would she survive in the wild? During the following months I did all I could to get her psychiatric care. (Only more than half a year later, those efforts were bringing any results at all, and not very promising ones.)
Over the months, my perspective shifted. From worrying about Alma to realizing that I had neglected my other children for Alma. When the rest of the family slowly took up the void left by Alma, I realized that I had been one of those parents who forced the other children to live in the shadow of a domineering sibling. While it was happening, I thought I managed. Through being alert, we could usually prevent Alma from running away too far. And when she did, we learned not to call the police (since they could never act proportionally). If she threw food around her or broke crockery, I could clean it up. Although she occupied the kitchen and other rooms too with little regard to the rest of us, we managed to cook for the family and keep things reasonably clean. Sometimes I even rationalized the situation through reasoning that it could be good for the other children to learn to deal with different kinds of personalities.
After Alma left I'm realizing that we didn't actually manage at all. Although we managed to cook and clean and keep everyone reasonably safe, we created a morally absurd environment. We had rules, but only the most basic of those applied to Alma, and she nonetheless challenged them. And whenever Alma was within hearing range, I needed to pretend that I thought that she was the most morally impeccable person that had ever existed. I knew that if I did otherwise, she would give me hell. So whenever she was around, I complied with her delusion.
Alma's older brother didn't feel that he had any place in this morally absurd universe. So he just withdrew. When Alma moved out, he rather rapidly started to act as a part of our family. When the goals and rules became decipherable, he was willing to participate on a corner. So while I lost one child, I won another.
Now that I have been running a morally normal family for ten months, I know that I neglected my other children as long as Alma lived with us. Although I believed that I didn't choose between my children, I did.
This can't be entirely unusual, because I know another (entirely normal, middle class) family in the very same village where more or less the same thing happened. A then nine year old girl dominated the home environment, over her a few years older brother and a few years younger sister. Then the girl got the idea to accuse her stepfather of sexual abuse. She took back her accusations when she realized their implications. After some time, no one seemed to believe that there was any truth in them. But by then she was already being pampered by the foster care system. Her mother fought to get her home again (and faced severe bullying from the social services) but the girl had learnt to manipulate the system. She told the legal courts that it was her mother who caused her to make up the lies about sexual abuse. When she met her mother she told her things like “you are a 2 out of 10”. Finally, three years after the family was split up this way, the mother decided to just stop pursuing her daughter anymore. She still worries a lot about her daughter's prospects in the foster care system. But she also recognizes that she now knows that she neglected her two other children before her most demanding child moved out. When the manipulative middle daughter moved out, she noticed that those two children could use some attention too. Attention they couldn't get when family life was about keeping their sister calm.
The curse of the perfect society
Over the years, Anders and I often posed one question: Where were all these highly demanding children before? Why don't we hear about children acting this way from previous generations?
I think the most probable answer is: They were outside of society. Saying I have so many needs and you have to cater to them all was just not accepted a generation or two ago. If children couldn't bear the demands put on children in general, they had little choice but to revolt or escape. They joined antisocial gangs that shoplifted, took recreational drugs or assaulted people. Or they developed accepted mental illnesses, like eating disorders, that were said to be caused by a flawed society.
That way, psychological problems were hidden behind social problems. When I grew up I was taught that some substances are so extremely addictive that if people try them twice, they can't stop taking them. They become slaves of the people providing the substances, who are eager to get ever more people addicted. If these substances can just be eradicated, the kind of people who become addicts will become normal, well-adjusted citizens instead.
There is a little truth in this. But only a little. By and large, drug pushers and other social ills were made the scapegoats of human psychological variation. Massive campaigns, even wars, were launched to combat those social evils. It paid off. Today children of most social classes are closely watched against social ills. That way, there is no longer any easily available escape route for children who feel that they can't conform with demands. Successful social engineering has taken away the cloak of social problems that previously hid less flattering sides of human psychology.
United in faith
Apparently, being prosocial is a lot easier for some people than for others. I can't say that I have a solution to that problem. Harry Thompson most probably is right that it is his personality to be obnoxious. The only thing I disagree with him over, is whether this is a reason for pride. In my world, it is a tragedy that some people are wired to always put themselves in the center. A tragedy to be handled as graciously as possible, but nonetheless a tragedy.
I think this is a major difference between parents in religious communities and secular parents. For the former, there are higher principles that apply to everyone. Also their current and future children. If any of their children disagree or simply can't keep up with such high levels of morality it is too bad. But, as it seems, they still feel justified to keep their convictions.
Secular parents, on the other hand, are supposed to accept their children for who they are. A parent of one girl diagnosed with Pathological Demand Avoidance recently told me that families sometimes split up because they can't solve the equation before them otherwise: Demand-avoidant children take offense from having to follow rules. Normal children take offense when someone is exempt from all rules. In such a situation, splitting the family is the only way that the true personality of every child can blossom.
I think that this difference is one reason why people in some religious communities can have more children: Because they believe in a god that is bigger than both them and their children, and that restricts the range of acceptable behavior. If some of their children renounce their parents' religion and choose to act in ways they find unacceptable, they can't do much more than let go and genuinely wish them good luck, while keeping to their own faith.
And although I'm not formally religious, I came to choose that road too. If I wanted to frame it in modern utilitarian and rationalist terms, I could say that I'm choosing the way of the majority of my children because they are the majority and that choice creates the most utility. But that would not be true. The truth is that I'm keeping my own moral principles and that the majority of my other children, thankfully, adhere to those principles as much as I do. We never formally agreed on those rules as a compromise. Instead, it is a faith we share, however that happened. This shared faith keeps us together.

Harry Thompson, The PDA Paradox: The Highs and Lows of My Life on a Little-Known Part of the Autism Spectrum, 2019, 61 percent of e-book
Harry Thompson, The PDA Paradox: The Highs and Lows of My Life on a Little-Known Part of the Autism Spectrum, 2019, 61 percent of e-book
Harry Thompson, The PDA Paradox: The Highs and Lows of My Life on a Little-Known Part of the Autism Spectrum, 2019, 61 percent of e-book
Harry Thompson, The PDA Paradox: The Highs and Lows of My Life on a Little-Known Part of the Autism Spectrum, 2019, 87 percent of e-book

I rarely comment on blogs these days, but your series on the evolutionary role of "madness" and religion has been profoundly thought-provoking.
What struck me most was your insight about religion serving as a boundary-maintenance system that makes large-scale cooperation possible. Modern society has largely forgotten this function, treating religion as merely a collection of supernatural beliefs rather than recognizing its role in solving fundamental coordination problems.
Your "mental hospital" metaphor perfectly captures the dilemma many families face today. Without shared moral frameworks beyond individual preference, how do we justify maintaining any boundaries at all? I've seen this same pattern play out in communities across America - when we elevate individual authenticity as the highest good, we inadvertently create environments hostile to cooperation and deeply challenging for child-rearing.
Most provocatively, you've highlighted how certain "collective frameworks" solved coordination problems that rational self-interest alone cannot. This raises uncomfortable questions about whether purely individualistic frameworks can sustain civilization without borrowing moral capital from traditions they've rejected.
The declining birthrates and increasing social fragmentation in secular societies suggest we haven't fully reckoned with what we've lost. Your analysis helps explain why these patterns aren't merely coincidental but structurally related to our shift away from shared meaning systems.
Looking forward to more of your insights.
Thank you for this incredibly powerful piece. I have a moderately SN child and relate to so much of it.