Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mike Randolph — M Raige's avatar

I rarely comment on blogs these days, but your series on the evolutionary role of "madness" and religion has been profoundly thought-provoking.

What struck me most was your insight about religion serving as a boundary-maintenance system that makes large-scale cooperation possible. Modern society has largely forgotten this function, treating religion as merely a collection of supernatural beliefs rather than recognizing its role in solving fundamental coordination problems.

Your "mental hospital" metaphor perfectly captures the dilemma many families face today. Without shared moral frameworks beyond individual preference, how do we justify maintaining any boundaries at all? I've seen this same pattern play out in communities across America - when we elevate individual authenticity as the highest good, we inadvertently create environments hostile to cooperation and deeply challenging for child-rearing.

Most provocatively, you've highlighted how certain "collective frameworks" solved coordination problems that rational self-interest alone cannot. This raises uncomfortable questions about whether purely individualistic frameworks can sustain civilization without borrowing moral capital from traditions they've rejected.

The declining birthrates and increasing social fragmentation in secular societies suggest we haven't fully reckoned with what we've lost. Your analysis helps explain why these patterns aren't merely coincidental but structurally related to our shift away from shared meaning systems.

Looking forward to more of your insights.

Isha Yiras Hashem's avatar

Thank you for this incredibly powerful piece. I have a moderately SN child and relate to so much of it.

42 more comments...

Ready for more?